LATEST NEWS
| Research News |
| Research Horizons magazine |
NEWS ARCHIVES
Research Horizons Magazine
July 11, 2002
Ice That Burns: Gas Hydrates Offer a Potential Energy Reserve, Danger to Petroleum Exploration & Global Warming Concern
 |
||||
|
||||
Burning ice.
That apparent contradiction describes methane gas hydrates, a solid form of methane and water normally found in sediment beneath the sea floor.
Methane - natural gas - is produced by the decomposition of organic material
in the sediment. As the methane diffuses through the sediment, it combines
with water at the low temperatures and high pressures beneath the ocean
to produce an ice-like solid.
Touted as a potential energy source for a power hungry world, methane gas hydrates are really much more. Indeed, they may contribute to global warming, and could represent a potential threat to deep-sea petroleum production.
At the Georgia Institute of Technology, an interdisciplinary group of researchers studies gas hydrates from all these angles, coordinated by the Focused Research Program on Gas Hydrates. The work includes modeling, sea floor exploration, a novel chemical sensing system for continuous underwater monitoring, biological research and geo-technical studies with laboratory-grown hydrates in sediments.
 |
||||
|
||||
Methane gas hydrates exist along the continental margins worldwide, most
in oceanic sediments hundreds of meters below the sea floor in water depths
of more than 500 meters - or in permafrost areas. The U.S.
Geological Survey estimates that gas hydrates off the U.S. coast or
in Alaskan permafrost could contain 300 times the amount of methane available
from conventional reserves. These hydrates exist as disseminated deposits,
chunks several centimeters across, and sometimes concentrated layers.
But producing methane from gas hydrates faces some daunting challenges.
"If you could get these hydrates out of the sea floor, you'd have
a concentrated form of natural gas," says Carolyn
Ruppel, associate professor of geophysics in Georgia Tech's School
of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences and coordinator of the gas hydrate
program. "But a key question is whether it would take more energy
to extract the gas hydrates than the gas may provide."
Aside from the difficulty of deep-sea operations, mining the hydrates
could destabilize the ocean floor or even trigger the runaway de-stabilization
of the hydrates. The methane might be tapped by pumping heated liquid
into the hydrate deposits to dissociate and recover the gas, but this
would be an energy-intensive operation. Another alternative would be to
drill through the hydrate layers into pools of free gas below - a potential
hazard.
And methane production presumes the ability to identify large hydrate deposits - something scientists are only now discovering. As part of a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)-sponsored multi-university research team aboard the RV Atlantis last autumn, Ruppel helped explore an area off the South Carolina coast known as the Blake Ridge. There, researchers found hydrates just above the ocean floor and filmed the formation of a hydrate cluster from a methane bubble. Through such explorations, scientists hope to learn more about where to find deposits of gas hydrates - without widespread drilling.
Later this year, Ruppel - along with Assistant Professor Daniel
Lizarralde from the School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences and colleagues
from Rice University and Scripps Institute of Oceanography - will explore
hydrates in the Gulf of Mexico as part of a project sponsored by the National
Science Foundation.
"We will be trying to measure heat, the volume of methane coming
out, and the rate that fluid is flowing from the sea floor," she
explains. "This information may give us a good handle on what's going
on deeper in the sediments and how to predict the location of the gas
hydrates."
Continuous chemical monitoring underwater
Boris Mizaikoff specializes in underwater optical sensing. An assistant professor in the School of Chemistry and Biochemistry, he and his colleagues have developed a compact sensing system able to continuously measure organic compounds deep beneath the ocean surface.
 |
||||
|
||||
Known as Spectroscopy using Chemical sensors for Undersea Based Applications
(S.C.U.B.A.), the system uses a chemically modified fiber-optic sensor
connected to a Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometer - operating
within a cylindrical pressure vessel less than a meter long. The special
polymer coating on the optical fiber reversibly absorbs organic compounds
from the water. An infrared light source excites the absorbed molecules
via the evanescent field guided outside the fiber, whose absorptions are
analyzed by the FTIR. This produces qualitative and quantitative measures
of compounds present.
"Rather than taking a sample, bringing it to the lab and putting
it into a spectrometer, we want to bring the measurement device to the
sample so we can do in-situ analysis," explains Mizaikoff. "That
allows us to do these measurements continuously and under fairly harsh
conditions."
S.C.U.B.A. has already shown its ability to measure a range of organic
compounds, including hydrocarbons and chlorinated hydrocarbons. With support
from the U.S. Department of Energy
through the University of Mississippi, Mizaikoff and his colleagues are
developing an optical sensor system that will allow accurate methane measurement.
Growing and studying hydrates in the lab
Scientists lack clear understanding of how gas hydrates form in sediments - and how their formation affects the stability of the ocean floor. Carlos Santamarina, a professor in the School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, hopes to provide answers by growing gas hydrates in "dirty systems," that is, at mineral surfaces and within different types of soils.
In a process he compares to medical diagnosis, Santamarina and his colleagues
use electromagnetic and elastic waves to monitor hydrate growth, studying
the formation process to learn about its effects on sediment response.
Instead of methane - which forms hydrates in sediments very slowly - they
grow the icy structures from tetrahydrofuran (THF) so they can reproduce
the very lengthy natural hydrate formation in shorter laboratory time.
In addition, they study the formation of hydrate monolayers on minerals
using atomic force microscopy.
Hydrate deposits in seafloor sediments may form "lenses," like
water forms ice layers in the soil during the winter months in northern
states. In spring, if the ice melts faster than the water can dissipate,
the soil becomes unstable and can cause extensive damage to highways.
"If methane hydrates form these lenses under the sea floor and become
destabilized for whatever reason - petroleum production or climatic change
- we could have massive landslides on the sea floor," he says.
A concern for drilling, climate change
While the value of gas hydrates as a future energy source remains uncertain,
the hazards they pose to production of conventional energy are clear.
Oil companies are running out of reserves in shallow waters, forcing them
to operate in areas where they may drill through hydrate formations. While
they may eventually be able to produce energy from these hydrates, the
more immediate concern is the potential hazards that gas hydrates may
pose for oil drilling.
"If you are drilling into the gas hydrate, you have to worry that the hydrate could suddenly dissociate, leading to collapse of the sediment supporting the drill stem," says Ruppel.
Perturbations of the sea floor can produce still bigger problems. Major
sea floor slides can cause tsunamis, large oceanic waves that bring catastrophic
damage to low-lying coastal areas.
Beyond energy interests, methane gas hydrates may also play a role in
global warming. Even slight warming could free significant amounts of
methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
"You'd have to warm the deep ocean waters by just a few degrees,"
notes Ruppel. "There is a time delay built into the system, so it
would take quite a while for the sediments to heat up. But if even a portion
of the methane released from hydrates gets out of the oceans and into
the atmosphere, it could exacerbate global warming and lead to a synergy
between destruction of hydrate, release of methane and climate change."
As an alternative source of energy, a hazard to conventional energy production and a global warming concern, "burning ice" is indeed a contradiction.
For more information, visit the Web site for the Focused Research Program on Gas Hydrates at: http://hydrate.eas.gatech.edu/gthydrates/
RESEARCH NEWS & PUBLICATIONS OFFICE
Georgia Institute of Technology
75 Fifth Street, N.W., Suite 100
Atlanta, Georgia 30308 USA
MEDIA RELATIONS CONTACTS:
John Toon (404-894-6986); E-mail:
john.toon@edi.gatech.edu; Fax: (404-894-4545) or Jane Sanders (404-894-2214);
E-mail: jane.sanders@edi.gatech.edu.
TECHNICAL CONTACT: Carolyn Ruppel, School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332-0340. (Telephone: 404-894-0231)(E-mail: cdr@piedmont.eas.gatech.edu)
Writer: John Toon